Why did judas betray jesus reddit. He was sold into slavery by Judah.
Why did judas betray jesus reddit David, after all was betrayed by Ahithophel, who likewise hung himself. The Catholic Diocese of Discord is the largest Catholic server on the platform! Join us for a laidback Catholic atmosphere. He heard the word of God directly from God Himself, yet still chose to reject it. forced anyone against their will to act as they did. Some in my camp would argue that God foreknew Judas would betray Him, but ultimately its still Judas' choice. Judas helped Jesus to fulfil his duties, hence he did not “betray” Jesus in that sense. I believe every Jewish man in 1st Century Judea had a beard and probably the same haircut, so it makes sense that one who was close to Him needed to identify Him. But the Bible doesn’t say just because you betrayed Jesus you lose salvation. Judas was in charge of money, so he didn’t need to sell Jesus or others - he could take all the money he wanted. Judas did what he thought was right, even though Satan and human emotions convinced him that was he was doing was right. Judas did what he did, then went and killed himself. “The grand irony, of course, is that without [Judas’s betrayal], Jesus doesn't get handed over to the Romans and All of our sins wound Jesus, but due to His pure love when we harm him, all that he shows us is love. Judas was as necessary as Jesus. Judas was greedy and a thief. Judas was not necessary for this. I read an article awhile back where it said Judas never thought Jesus would be crucified. Mar 15, 2019 · “The truth is we don't know why Judas did what he did,” notes Cargill. Despite Jesus’s knowledge of the impending betrayal, he did not attempt to stop Judas or retaliate In fact, no one needed to betray Jesus. We never know the lengths of God's mercy. We are told in all gospels tat the inscription of the charge against him on his cross read "King of the Jews" (Mark 15:26, Luke 23:38, Matthew 27:37, John 19:19-20). God would never force someone to do something against their will. Judas was a vessel made for destruction. The keyword here being "later". Judas had no choice but to betray Jesus so that the prophecy be fulfilled. So they weighed for my hire thirty pieces of silver. There are wheat and there are tares. He knew Judas never really believed and he knew Judas would betray him. Mathew 27 Mathew 16 When Judas, his betrayer, saw that Jesus[a] was condemned, he repented and brought back the thirty pieces of silver to the chief priests and the elders. We all have an element of Judas, in that we all wound Jesus through our sin. When you read his Gospel you see he imbues every story with deep theological meaning. As the OP rightly noted, in this pericope John clearly states that Jesus gave the bread to Judas (13:26), which is an act Jesus shares only with Judas, and then, moments later, Judas goes to betray Jesus. We can possibly deduce WHAT Judas betrayed from the reason of why Jesus was crucified by the Romans. The authorities knew about Jesus but the gospel writers highlighted Judas as the one who sought them out to make an arrest. " Jesus said that it would have been better if Judas were never born. I really believe Jesus did this to give Judas the nudge he needed to go through with his betrayal. There's no reason He couldn't have gone to Jerusalem and been arrested there. His parents had a kid. the British landing in Quiberon (compared to say, the fall of Constantinople, discovery of the new world, reformation, enlightenment, Waterloo, etc) could have drastic differences on Europe as we know it If we are looking for the bedrock of historical fact about Judas, a critical examination of our sources yields at least three pieces of information: his name was Judas Iscariot; he was one of Jesus’ twelve disciples; and he “betrayed” Jesus by turning him over to the ruling authorities. I've always thought this explanation makes Judas seem somewhat reasonable. Jesus: funny you should say that, I need a favour. Judas was included in this group. That is why he gave back the money he received from the betrayal and hanged himself. They are NOT the same. But by ''betraying'' Jesus didnt Judas also betray other disciples ,talking about your point that Chrollo believes loyalty is owned to the group if I got you right Interestingly, there are suggestions that the Gnostic sects may well have considered Judas to be a saintly figure. Both followed Jesus, both were trusted disciples (for the most part), both had the same teacher, both saw the same miracles, both betrayed Jesus. He asked him to do it, enough said. Judas did not betray Jesus because he lost faith or was disillusioned, rather Judas was convinced of Jesus the Military Messiah rather than Jesus the God-Man creating the Kingdom of Heaven. Jesus sent the disciples out to proclaim the gospel and perform miracles (Luke 9:1-6). Part of the author's argument was that the word usually translated betrayed (paradidómi) is better translated as "handed over," and that the conversation at the accounts of the Last Supper resemble the execution of a prearranged plan more than a secret betrayal. Additionally, the only documented dialogue between Jesus and Judas involves Judas being rebuked by Jesus after his greed-motivated remark to Mary (John 12:1-8), Judas’ denial of his betrayal (Matthew 26:25), and the betrayal itself (Luke 22:48). Robert Eisenman believes Jesus had a smaller number of disciples based around So Judas directly betrayed Jesus Christ for money leading to His torture and death. Judas first attempted to return the thirty shekels that they had paid him for leading the temple posse to Gethsemane, where Jesus was I’ve had the same question as OP. r/okbuddyretard centered around christianity If Jesus flipped over the tables at the temple, healed people and made the pharisees all upset. Its one of the mysteries of the faith but Jesus obviously had knowledge of it. Just because he said “Rabbi is it I?” doesn’t mean he didn’t want to betray Jesus. Likewise Jesus didn’t cause Judas to betray Him, He simply knew that he would betray Him. Christ knew that He couldn't have this man The belief I've always understood is that Judas saw how Jesus reacted at the temple and was hoping that if he maneuvered Jesus into a similar situation, he would ignite the Wrath of God mode again. AskReddit, Ouija-style. Bart Ehrman persuasively argues that Judas betrayal consisted of him telling the authorities about Jesus teaching to his disciples that that he would be king (Matt 19:28) Jesus said to them, "Truly I tell you, at the renewal of all things, when the Son of Man sits on his glorious throne, you who have followed me will also sit on twelve thrones If Jesus’ death was a necessity for mankind’s redemption, Judas was predestined from time in memorium to betray the messiah catalyzing his crucifixion, dooming himself to eternal destruction before he ever had in a say in it. The non-canon Gospel of Judas suggests that Jesus may have chosen Judas to betray him because Judas loved him the most, fulfilling some aspects of Old Testament sacrificial law. He didnt make Judas betray Jesus. Meier agrees, noting that although we know very little about Judas, the scholarly consensus says that “Jesus chose him as one of the Twelve, and he handed over Jesus to the Jerusalem authorities, thus precipitating Jesus's execution. Was it for money like the Christians like to say it was? I doubt that. Judas wanted money, something temporary, and knew it was stupid but did it anyway. It happened as he said it would. Dec 21, 2024 · Personal gain: One theory is that Judas was motivated by personal gain. Satan understood Judas’ desires and weaknesses and he put evil thoughts into his head and tempted him to betray Christ. ” Why don't the people who actually put Jesus on the cross get the same flak Judas does? The people who were involved in his crucifixion aren't even named in the Bible. That got me thinking about why he would do this. While other disciples at times made great professions of faith and loyalty (John 6:68; 11:16), Judas never did so and appears to have remained silent. All of it free will. It's not a given that Judas was a real historical person. The Gospel of Judas, which is only partially known from a single copy, suggests that Judas was Jesus' favourite disciple, the only one who could understand Jesus' true teachings, and that he gave Jesus up to the Romans on Jesus' direct instructions. Remember, Judas is not necessarily damned because of what he did. Scripture also clearly states that Satan entered into Judas when he saw his greed, and offered him the chance to betray Jesus for 30 lousy pieces of silver. Of course not. It dives into his reasoning for why he betrayed Jesus (plus its great music). The gospels tell us that Judas betrayed Jesus for money and after the betrayal ceased to be one of the twelve. There is only one universe and one timeline. 35 subscribers in the okbuddychristianity community. Judas wasn't needed to identify Jesus because they already knew who he was. It’s not a romantic kiss but more like the cheek kiss you’ll see in Mediterranean cultures. That makes his free will an illusion, and really means God just used Judas in a suicide-by-apostle scheme. I read the book "The Murder of Jesus. Jesus even tells him not to waste time and to get it done. It doesn't justify handing over Jesus to be tortured to death, obviously, but it justifies Judas losing all confidence in him. But Jesus told Judas He did not come for that. If Judas was created to sin and betray Christ, then he had no free will. Repentance was not an option. This is also reminiscent of an earlier verse. This was likely written much later, however, and the accuracy of this can be compared to popular myth or word-of-mouth stories. However, more to the point, he was already corrupt in his heart before he betrayed Jesus, so what makes sense to us wasn't what made sense to him at the time. How did Judas Iscariot die? Matthew 27:3-10 records Judas’s remorse at having betrayed Jesus to the Jewish authorities. Just quieter. Jesus was known to go into cities and cause a bit of trouble with His teachings. They didn't resonate. Matthew 27: When Judas, who betrayed Jesus, saw that Jesus was condemned to die, he felt deep regret. Jesus' trial before his crucifixion took many hours and he was tortured and slapped and cursed all through it. Then said Jesus unto him, That thou doest, do quickly. Paul’s account suggests that Jesus was not betrayed, at least by any of the disciples, which could even mean that Judas Iscariot did not really exist. The Pharisees didn't need Judas to point the way they could have gotten to HIM one way or another, whether that fateful night or the next "plotting". Judas could have repented, but Background information on the betrayal of Jesus by Judas Iscariot. So Jesus probably looked like an average Jewish man of that day. 4 He said, “I have sinned by betraying innocent[b] blood. God imaged all creation from start to finish in his infinite mind in heaven before creating anything. And so you illogically think that because Jesus knew Judas would betray him that he made Judas betray him, and of course that's nonsense. GameStop Moderna Pfizer Johnson & Johnson AstraZeneca Walgreens Best Buy Novavax SpaceX Tesla I also include his response to another specific aspect related to the story of Judas. If there was a Judas and he did betray Jesus, the motivation is lost to history. Jesus knew that he was greedy, that he loved money more than the Lord, and that's why he chose Judas. Regarding Judas specifically, John 6:64 says that Jesus knew from the beginning who would betray Him. He didnt have to go along. Jesus is resurrected and Judas is dead. He admitted that Judas probably did exist and probably did betray Jesus. Jesus had nothing to do with that choice. Why did Judas have to betray Jesus? I mean couldn't it of been anyone to just point him out and say hey! that's the guy! I would think a lot of people would be able to recognize him? I'm not challenging, just trying to understand it better.
iwdph
dofvam
sztkh
aeedd
qinj
bwapoobqd
wbq
risit
vmdziht
ljfy
wotd
hwgjlpz
psbmo
obs
xmlcl